"Only Love Can Hurt Like This": Validation and Healing in a Paperback

"Only Love Can Hurt Like This” by  Paige Toon isn't just another romance novel - it's the antidote to the problematic "women's stories" that have flooded our screens and bookshelves lately.

Wren's world shatters when she discovers her fiancé's heart belongs to another. Seeking refuge from her broken dreams, she retreats to her father's Indiana farm, where summer stretches endlessly before her. But this isn't just an escape - it's a collision course with the very people she's spent years resenting: her stepmother Sheryl and stepsister Bailey, whom she's blamed for her parents' divorce. What unfolds is a difficult road which forces Wren to confront truths she's long buried beneath her anger.

Enter our brooding leading man - two of them actually -  the Fredrickson brothers, who couldn't be more different: Jonas, the heartbreaker, and Anders, who is carrying the weight of his wife's tragic death three years prior. 

The chemistry between Wren and Anders crackles across sun-drenched cornfields and beneath starlit skies, but Anders is keeping a secret which threatens to destroy everything they're building. Their connection deepens with each passing day, yet the threat of devastating consequences looms like storm clouds on the horizon.

This is a love story however, Toon’s genius lies in how she sidesteps the usual romantic tropes and creates a tale of real depth. When Wren and Anders first meet, the electricity is immediate yet their deeper connection takes time and feels earned rather than manufactured. And all of that feeling is earned within a slow dance of healing, set to the rhythm of the harvest. Healing is also found in transformative metaphors as Wren breathes new life into an old airstream caravan nicknamed Bambi - like stripping away old paint and rust, she's peeling back layers of hurt to reveal something beautiful underneath. Toon also addresses sensitive subjects such as Wren’s fear of being “left behind” in a haunting melody throughout this work. 

Follow Paige Toon on Instagram

For Toon, Indiana setting isn't just backdrop - it's character in itself, with fireflies dancing through warm evenings, the smell of barbecue drifting across property lines, and generations of history etched into every farmhouse. Summer unfolds in a series of pitch-perfect scenes: neighbouring families gathering for lakeside swims, impromptu movie nights under the stars 

Paige Toon is a British author from Buckinghamshire, specializing in contemporary romantic fiction. With a degree from the University of Manchester, she has established herself as a bestselling novelist known for emotionally compelling narratives. Her writing style blends heartfelt storytelling with relatable characters across multiple romantic and women's fiction novels. Published works include "One Perfect Summer," "Johnny Be Good," "Pictures of Lily," "You Had Me At Hello," "The Longest Holiday," "Child of the Sun," and "Only Love Can Hurt Like This." Toon has consistently achieved commercial success, with multiple books ranking on bestseller lists and garnering significant reader popularity in the UK and internationally.

I'll confess - the cover drew me in, reminiscent of "It Ends With Us." But where that story (and its recent film adaptation) stumbled catastrophically in its handling of domestic violence, Toon's novel soars. Instead of the bait-and-switch that left many "It Ends With Us" viewers reeling, this book delivers exactly what it promises: a thoughtful exploration of love, loss, and healing.

"Only Love Can Hurt Like This" isn't just a romance - it's a balm for readers burned by recent mainstream offerings. It proves that love stories can be both achingly tender and unflinchingly honest, leaving you in tears for all the right reasons. This isn't just entertainment - it's validation and healing bound in paperback form.

View on Amazon